Redington Butterstick
Review: Redington Butterstick (580-3 & 580-4)
By Margie McKnight
I’ve been lucky enough to fish both the older Heritage model (the beautiful teal-orange striped classic) and the newer Sunshine Yellow version, both in 5wt, and while they each have their quirks, they share the same smooth, full-flex feel that makes fiberglass rods so damn fun to fish.
Casting & Action
Both versions of the Butterstick are true glass wands—they load deep, flex beautifully, and reward a relaxed, smooth casting stroke. If you’re coming from a fast-action graphite rod, the Butterstick will force you to slow down, which is exactly what i needed. The older 3-piece Heritage model has a slightly softer, more classic feel, while the newer 4-piece version stiffened up just a touch, giving it a little more control without losing that signature glass flex.
Build & Aesthetics
The Heritage model has a vintage vibe, with its mesmerizing blue-and-bright orange wraps and glossy finish that just screams “old-school.” It’s a head-turner and feels like a throwback to the golden age of glass rods. The newer Butter yellow version keeps the retro aesthetic but modernizes the build slightly with a smoother, more refined finish and an additional section for easier travel. Both have cork grips that feel great in hand, and the aluminum reel seats hold everything snugly.
Margie fishing with the 580-3 on the Provo river.
On the Water
This rod truly shines in dry season. It’s delicate enough to protect light tippet, but it still has enough backbone to handle a 20-inch trout in a pocket water run. It’s not the rod I’d grab for punching through wind or making long-distance casts, but for intimate, precise fishing, it’s an absolute joy.
Final Thoughts
If you love slow, buttery casts and feeling every fish in full fiberglass glory, the Redington Butterstick is a must-have. The older Heritage 3-piece is a true classic, while the newer 4-piece offers a bit more portability and a slightly refined action. Either way, this rod delivers pure fun—the kind that reminds you why you fell in love with fly fishing in the first place.